Download PDF The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, by Michael MacLear
Well, book The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear will certainly make you closer to what you want. This The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear will be constantly buddy any type of time. You may not forcedly to constantly complete over checking out a publication basically time. It will certainly be only when you have leisure and also investing couple of time to make you really feel enjoyment with exactly what you read. So, you can obtain the definition of the notification from each sentence in guide.
The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, by Michael MacLear
Download PDF The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, by Michael MacLear
Checking out a publication The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear is type of very easy task to do each time you want. Also reviewing every single time you want, this task will certainly not disturb your other activities; many individuals frequently read guides The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear when they are having the extra time. What concerning you? What do you do when having the leisure? Don't you invest for ineffective things? This is why you should get the publication The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear and attempt to have reading habit. Reviewing this e-book The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear will certainly not make you useless. It will provide a lot more perks.
When visiting take the encounter or ideas types others, book The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear can be a good source. It holds true. You could read this The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear as the resource that can be downloaded and install right here. The way to download is also simple. You could see the link page that our company offer and after that buy guide making an offer. Download and install The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear and also you could put aside in your own device.
Downloading the book The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear in this internet site listings can make you much more benefits. It will certainly reveal you the best book collections and also finished compilations. Many books can be located in this internet site. So, this is not just this The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear Nonetheless, this book is described review since it is an impressive publication to offer you much more chance to get experiences and also thoughts. This is straightforward, check out the soft data of guide The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear as well as you get it.
Your impression of this publication The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear will lead you to obtain what you exactly need. As one of the impressive publications, this book will certainly offer the existence of this leaded The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear to accumulate. Also it is juts soft file; it can be your collective file in gizmo and various other gadget. The crucial is that usage this soft file publication The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear to review and also take the perks. It is what we mean as book The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, By Michael MacLear will enhance your thoughts and mind. Then, reviewing book will certainly also improve your life high quality better by taking great activity in balanced.
The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975
- Sales Rank: #1090669 in Books
- Brand: St Martins Pr
- Published on: 1981-09
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Binding: Hardcover
- 367 pages
- Great product!
Most helpful customer reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful.
The Definitive Guide to America's War in Vietnam
By Christopher A. Leach
Michael Maclear is a Canadian, and wrote this book from a non-American perspective. As such, it offers an objective view of America's involvement in Southeast Asia and the Vietnam War. I cannot recommend this book more strongly for anyone who wants a comprehensive understanding of one of America's darkest moments.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful.
A Canadian view of the French and American Wars in Vietnam...
By John P. Jones III
Michael Maclear is a Canadian journalist and filmmaker. Although his country was not involved in the war, other than serving as a place of refuge for those Americans who did not want to participate, he, and his Japanese wife developed their own obsession with it, which spanned a couple of decades, and including numerous stays in Vietnam. He waited the proverbial "decent interval" after the war, certainly for a journalist, to relate what happened. The book was published in 1981. The title, though a convenient round number, understates the period of the war(s) covered by more than a couple of years; it was from the defeat of the Japanese occupying forces (and their French Vichy collaborators) in 1945, until North Vietnamese tanks rolled through the Presidential Palace in Saigon in 1975.
As Maclear indicates in the introduction, the book is primarily about the American War. In 350 pages, only the first 50 are devoted to the French involvement, until the fall of Dien Bien Phu. The author conducted numerous interviews with the participants, from the high-level policy makers to the "grunts" who fought the war on the ground. Though I have read numerous books on the war, and did my own year, "on the ground," I found much new and unique material in this excellent account. Maclear sets the tone of his book early on in the introduction: "The interviews with the senior policy-makers reveal an ignorance of, or a withholding of facts that were always available. Motives and objectives are no clearer now than at the time: indeed, they are often shown as non-existent. And so the rationale for the sacrifice thins."
The work commences with Major Archimedes Patti of the OSS - Office of Strategic Services - the forerunner to the CIA, who was in Vietnam in 1945, encouraging resistance to the Japanese occupation. The principal entity that is fighting on the side of the Americans is led by, yes, Ho Chi Minh. Among the material that I found new, was Patti citing President Roosevelt, as saying in 1943: "that Americans would not be dying in the Pacific tonight if it hadn't been for the short-sighted greed of the French and the British and the Dutch. Shall we allow them to do it all, all over again?" Yes, there was the very real option of establishing short-term protectorates after WW II, as a prelude to independence. Instead, we allowed the defeated colonial powers to assume control of their colonies, necessitating "wars of liberation" by the inhabitants, including the longest one, Vietnam.
Maclear follows a now very familiar parabola (at least for me) from the Marines landing on the beaches at Da Nang, in 1965, through the troop built-up to 500,000 plus, and hitting so many of the "touchstones" of the war along the way, from "search and destroy" missions, the Tet offensive, the battle for Hue and Khe Sanh, My Lai, the bombing and invasion of Cambodia to the final denouement commencing with the collapse of ARVN forces in the Central Highlands in 1975. Two of the interviewees that Maclear heavily draws upon are Tim O'Brien of The Things They Carried fame, as well as several other books, and Jim Webb, of Fields of Fire, and several others, fame. Webb is served as US Senator from Virginia.
Time and time again, Maclear demonstrates a true understanding of the actual events in the country, and the attitude of the participants, particularly the "grunts." He relates their "Fort Apache" attitude when they were on patrol, and all civilians were seen as "hostiles." He knew of the "Coke girls," 9 and 10 year old Vietnamese girls who would follow around, and sell cold Cokes to the GI's. He relates a couple anecdotes that underscored how the American Army was disintegrating under the strain of the impossible position it was placed in. For example, he quotes Senator Eugene McCarthy: "I'm inclined to believe that the war would have ended just about when it did, even if there had been no protest, if I had not campaigned, because they didn't end it on policy finally: they just ended it because they were losing it, and - you know- the soldiers wouldn't fight." And related to what was called the battle of "Hamburger Hill": "With general morale near zero, and with at least 500,000, or nine-tenths of the US force as rear-echelon and preferring it that way, the US military command order what Congressmen called `an absolutely senseless' offensive in the A Shau valley...The public fury in the United states was such that Defense Secretary Melvin Laird had to rebuke openly the military command...(there was) a $10,000 bounty of Lieutenant-Colonel Weldon Honeycutt, the officer who ordered and led the attack....the bounty for the life of the Lieutenant -Colonel was not unique except for the amount. There were bounties ranging from $50 to $1000 offered for the killing of unpopular officers." Our "troubled Army in Vietnam" as Newsweek' cover once proclaimed.
The only point that I (strongly!) disagree with was Maclear's estimate that over two-thirds of the troops who had been in Vietnam were designated as requiring psychological care. Hum! But overall, Maclear got it all so right. 5-stars, plus.
16 of 19 people found the following review helpful.
Opportunity Lost
By Michael Bousfield
When I first read this book I had little knowledge of the real politiks that were being played out and the reasons why.
However, on completion I came to the conclusion that the USA had missed a golden opportunity to secure Vietnam as a loyal ally amongst the Asian dominos.
The irony of the whole affair was reinforced in this most informative analysis. What if the US decided to recognise Hoh and his government and ignore the French. It must have come oh so close. While Hoh was a member of the Communist party he was ultimately a nationalist who openly recognised and respected the democratic ideals of the USA. Hoh's numerous (and most polite) written entreaties to Truman and his use of the American declaration of independence go further to support this assumption.
Billions of $ were invested by the US supporting the French in the French-Indochina war and then during their own conflict in Vietnam War. What a waste, what a cost...
I can't help but think what a difference these $ would've made if US govt in 1945 seized the opportunity and helped Hoh, Giap and co develop the country and build strong diplomatic relations in a very strategic part of Asia proper.
The book appealed to me for many reasons, but particularly because of Mike Maclear's impartial, dispassionate treatise of the subject.
Australia, like the US, is still coming to terms with its' own Vietnam War legacy. Many veterans are making the journey back to Vietnam to try to heal old wounds - I think that this book should be compuslory reading for all those who were there and for all those who see futility of war.
The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, by Michael MacLear PDF
The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, by Michael MacLear EPub
The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, by Michael MacLear Doc
The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, by Michael MacLear iBooks
The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, by Michael MacLear rtf
The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, by Michael MacLear Mobipocket
The Ten Thousand Day War : Vietnam 1945-1975, by Michael MacLear Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar